Years before Kelce was jetting across the world to support Swift in Sydney, Australia, on her international tour, he was given the choice between his future girlfriendwas asked to play the game for a bit of harmless fun.

Damn, that’s messed up, I don’t want to kill any of them,” Kelce said, to which the host encouraged, “It’s just a game!”

Kelce continued to carefully mull over his choices. After hesitating, Kelce eventually admitted he would “kill” Grande, though he made a point to note that he thinks she’s great. Kelce was then left to pick between Perrywould be the marry,” Kelce concluded as he nodded his head in approval of the Hot N Cold singer.

Lucky for Kelce, who couldn’t have imagined at the time that he’d be in a relationshiptried to hire Swift’s backup dancers and “sabotage an entire arena tour.”

The pop star’s rivalry was well-noted — and Swift went as far as writing her hit 2015 song Bad Blood about their falling out.